Agency comparison
Conversion Fanatics vs Scott Shorter
Combined CRO and PPC management for ecommerce
CRO-led growth work for growth teams
Verdict. Conversion Fanatics has the higher editorial score on current public evidence, but the better choice depends on fit. Conversion Fanatics suits teams looking for combined CRO and PPC management for ecommerce; Scott Shorter suits teams looking for CRO-led growth work for growth teams. Note: Scott Shorter is profiled from an evidence scan pending editorial review.
Key differences
- Focus: both are CRO-led agencies with adjacent services, so the choice comes down to evidence, fit and terms.
- Pricing: Conversion Fanatics: Not publicly disclosed. Scott Shorter: From $1,000 / month (as published).
- AI: Conversion Fanatics shows no public AI approach; Scott Shorter shows AI used in parts of delivery.
- Location: Conversion Fanatics: Not confirmed. Scott Shorter: Australia.
- Editorial score: Conversion Fanatics 7.9, Scott Shorter 7.9.
Side-by-side facts
Every value comes from the same records as each agency's profile, where you can see verification status and sources.
| Field | Conversion Fanatics | Scott Shorter |
|---|---|---|
| Editorial score | 7.9 / 10 | 7.9 / 10 |
| Overall rank | #41 | #45 |
| Best for | Combined CRO and PPC management for ecommerce | CRO-led growth work for growth teams |
| Specialization | CRO-led with adjacent services | CRO-led with adjacent services |
| Headquarters | Not confirmed | Australia |
| Founded | Not published | Not published |
| Ownership | Not publicly disclosed | Not publicly disclosed |
| Pricing | Not publicly disclosed | From $1,000 / month (as published) |
| Pricing models | Not publicly disclosed | Monthly retainer |
| AI readiness | No public AI approach | AI used in parts of delivery |
| AEO offered | Not published | Yes |
| Business types | Ecommerce / DTC, B2C, Lead generation | Enterprise |
| Strongest verticals | Not specified | Not specified |
| Platforms | Shopify, Custom stacks | Not specified |
| Regions | North America | Asia-Pacific |
| Company sizes | Startups and small businesses, Medium-sized companies | Large companies and enterprise, Medium-sized companies, Startups and small businesses |
| Published case studies checked | 0 | 0 |
| Named clients recorded | 0 | 8 |
Score by criterion
| Criterion | Weight | Conversion Fanatics | Scott Shorter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Published proof of work | 25% | 6.5 | 7.0 |
| Experimentation rigor | 20% | 6.5 | 3.6 |
| CRO specialization depth | 15% | 7.0 | 6.5 |
| Commercial transparency | 15% | 5.0 | 6.0 |
| AI readiness | 10% | Unknown | 7.0 |
| Team and footprint | 10% | 5.0 | 3.5 |
| Third-party credentials | 5% | 5.0 | 3.0 |
| Editorial score | 100% | 7.9 | 7.9 |
Strengths and limitations
Conversion Fanatics strengths
- Stronger published proof of work: Aggregate win-rate claim
- Stronger CRO specialization: CRO plus PPC
Conversion Fanatics limitations
- Weaker AI readiness: no public evidence found
Scott Shorter strengths
- Stronger published proof of work: 8 client names and 1 case-study links found on the homepage
- Stronger AI readiness: The homepage describes AI-assisted services or tooling in several places
Scott Shorter limitations
- Weaker experimentation rigor: Methodology language (research, hypotheses, testing, QA) appears on the homepage
Which should you choose?
Choose Conversion Fanatics if
- You are an ecommerce business and want combined CRO and PPC management for ecommerce
- You run Shopify
Choose Scott Shorter if
- You are an enterprise business and want CRO-led growth work for growth teams
- You want published pricing before a sales call
- You also want answer engine optimization
- You prefer a team in Australia
Published evidence
Conversion Fanatics
No measured case studies checked yet.
Scott Shorter
No measured case studies checked yet.
Named clients: Golfbox, Compass, Exoo, The West Australian, Nerds You, grow play
Common questions
Is Conversion Fanatics or Scott Shorter better?
On our published method Conversion Fanatics scores higher (7.9 vs 7.9). Scores measure public evidence, not guaranteed results, so compare both against your business type (ecommerce, B2C, lead generation vs enterprise), budget and platform.
Sources
- Conversion Fanatics: Homepage · Conversion Fanatics · accessed 3 November 2026
- Best CRO agencies for ecommerce · Web Tonic · accessed 3 November 2026Published by a CRO agency or vendor that ranks itself in the list. We use it only to discover agencies, not as evidence of quality.
- Best CRO agencies ranking · PixelCrayons · accessed 3 November 2026
- Scott Shorter: Homepage · Scott Shorter · accessed 3 November 2026