Agency comparison

The Good Marketer vs Clean Commit

Researched Next review By the CRO Agency Index research desk
7.7

CRO-led growth work for Shopify brands

Clean Commit

#57 overall
7.7

Dedicated CRO and A/B testing for Shopify brands

Verdict. The Good Marketer has the higher editorial score on current public evidence, but the better choice depends on fit. The Good Marketer suits teams looking for CRO-led growth work for Shopify brands; Clean Commit suits teams looking for dedicated CRO and A/B testing for Shopify brands. Note: The Good Marketer and Clean Commit are profiled from an evidence scan pending editorial review.

Key differences

  • Focus: The Good Marketer is a CRO-led agency with adjacent services; Clean Commit is a dedicated CRO and experimentation agency.
  • Pricing: The Good Marketer: From £845 / month (as published). Clean Commit: From $5,950 / month (as published).
  • AI: The Good Marketer shows no public AI approach; Clean Commit shows no public AI approach.
  • Location: The Good Marketer: London, United Kingdom. Clean Commit: Not confirmed.
  • Editorial score: The Good Marketer 7.7, Clean Commit 7.7.

Side-by-side facts

Every value comes from the same records as each agency's profile, where you can see verification status and sources.

The Good Marketer and Clean Commit compared
FieldThe Good MarketerClean Commit
Editorial score7.7 / 107.7 / 10
Overall rank#67#57
Best forCRO-led growth work for Shopify brandsDedicated CRO and A/B testing for Shopify brands
SpecializationCRO-led with adjacent servicesDedicated CRO / experimentation
HeadquartersLondon, United KingdomNot confirmed
Founded2017Not published
OwnershipNot publicly disclosedNot publicly disclosed
PricingFrom £845 / month (as published)From $5,950 / month (as published)
Pricing modelsMonthly retainerMonthly retainer, Retainer with results guarantee
AI readinessNo public AI approachNo public AI approach
AEO offeredNot publishedNot published
Business typesB2B, B2C, Ecommerce / DTC, Retail, Lead generationEcommerce / DTC, B2C
Strongest verticalsNot specifiedNot specified
PlatformsShopify, WordPressShopify, Shopify Plus
RegionsUnited Kingdom, EuropeGlobal
Company sizesMedium-sized companies, Startups and small businessesMedium-sized companies
Published case studies checked00
Named clients recorded00

Score by criterion

CriterionWeightThe Good MarketerClean Commit
Published proof of work25%6.04.0
Experimentation rigor20%4.88.0
CRO specialization depth15%6.58.0
Commercial transparency15%6.57.0
AI readiness10%UnknownUnknown
Team and footprint10%5.83.0
Third-party credentials5%3.03.0
Editorial score100%7.77.7

Strengths and limitations

The Good Marketer strengths

  • Stronger commercial transparency: Publishes a price on its homepage
  • Stronger published proof of work: 0 client names and 8 case-study links found on the homepage

The Good Marketer limitations

  • Weaker AI readiness: no public evidence found

Clean Commit strengths

  • Stronger experimentation rigor: Methodology language (research, hypotheses, testing, QA) appears on the homepage; named testing tools: convert
  • Stronger CRO specialization: Its website presents conversion optimization and experimentation as the core of the business

Clean Commit limitations

  • Weaker AI readiness: no public evidence found

Which should you choose?

Choose The Good Marketer if

  • You are a B2B business and want CRO-led growth work for Shopify brands
  • You prefer a team in United Kingdom

Choose Clean Commit if

  • You are an ecommerce business and want dedicated CRO and A/B testing for Shopify brands
  • You want a CRO specialist rather than a generalist

Published evidence

The Good Marketer

No measured case studies checked yet.

Clean Commit

No measured case studies checked yet.

Common questions

Is The Good Marketer or Clean Commit better?

On our published method The Good Marketer scores higher (7.7 vs 7.7). Scores measure public evidence, not guaranteed results, so compare both against your business type (B2B, B2C, ecommerce vs ecommerce, B2C), budget and platform.

Sources

  1. The Good Marketer: Homepage · The Good Marketer · accessed 3 November 2026
  2. Clean Commit: Homepage · Clean Commit · accessed 3 November 2026